The Definitive NES Black Box Variant Guide

The Definitive Black Box Nes Guide

Click here to download a PDF version of this article

 

              OCTOBER, 1985. Nintendo would change the course of pop culture history forever with the release of the NES and its classic “Black Box” series that debuted with 17 games, all sharing a similar style so-called for the games simple graphics and uniform Black-colored boxes. No longer would you be deceived by intricate artwork that disappointed and overcompensated for lackluster gameplay. No — Nintendo was saying “what you see is what you get” with their pixelated 8-bit images that brought our favorite characters to life. From then through 1987 they would go on to release 13 more titles for a total of 30 Black Box games that spawned a new generation of video gaming and a slew of iconic characters that would go on to create some of the biggest franchises in pop culture today (Mario, we’re looking at you!).

These 30 titles have their own historical significance, but more interestingly, they also have a chronology and release history that has never had the proper light shed upon it. Wata Games tracks all the variants that exist for NES games, but what good does tracking it mean if it the history is still obscured? This feature will be shedding light specifically on U.S. Black Box Variants and how to properly identify them.

Many of us have collected these iconic titles for years, typically without paying much heed to the many differences that exist amongst their boxes. Since the mid-2000s, collectors have taken on the quest to track or at least make some sense to the different variations to create some semblance of how the physical components were altered over time and if there was a method to the seeming madness going on in Nintendo’s factories. With the changes in the market, some are coming to identify the true rarity of earlier releases of these games, while others are misled into believing that a “Hangtab” means it was a first print. Let’s dig into the progression of these boxes and why Super Mario Bros. has 11 box variants.

 

Before we begin: A Foreword

Many years of dedicated collecting, archiving, and tracking have gone into understanding the true nature of Black Box variants–not just by us, but by many NES collectors (a big nod from us to the work of “Braveheart”). Over the past decade, countless discussions have occurred within the collecting community to make some semblance of the seemingly arbitrary existence of these iconic games different box types, yet no consensus has been reached or documented and shared publicly. Our attempt here to pull it all together is just that–it is not meant as the be-all end-all, but rather as the most extensive and accurate list available to serve as a collector resource. Many of the publicly available dates and references are fuzzy and not definitive, and truths we have discovered about the history contradict even Nintendo’s public records or simple resources such as Wikipedia, even with information as simple as the true number of NES release titles (17 instead of the publicly listed numbers of 15 or 18).

At every instance of this feature we want to be clear that we are discussing Black Box “Box” variants, not Cartridge and Manual variants for black box games. Since many of the cart and manual variants follow the changes with boxes, and also because there is overlap of the cartridge and manual combinations across many box variants, we are limiting the focus on boxes to maintain a more straightforward and clear picture.

It is likely that more variants can and will be discovered over the coming decades as this hobby evolves, and that thought is exciting to us! We hope that we can rely on you, as part of the community, to fill gaps that need to be filled and add to our collective understanding of the history. After reading this, you may even discover a variant in your collection that has never been recognized. We look forward to adding to this evolving picture to clarify the history for us all and to make collecting that much more rewarding.

 

Let’s begin: Major NES Box Variants
STICKER SEALS, HANGTABS, “REV-A,” & THE SEAL OF QUALITY

If you’ve been collecting or buying games online, you’ll certainly see (if you haven’t already) words like “Hangtab,” “Rev-A,” “Round Seal”, and “First Print” among others thrown around to describe Black Box variants. But oftentimes it’s confusing to a buyer as to what these descriptors are really pointing out, or in many cases they’re only giving a snapshot of the box variant and missing the other pieces to the puzzle that identify it as to what it truly is. And to add to the confusion, you may even see information that misleads more than clarifies, such as the word  “Hangtab” being incorrectly conflated with “First Print,” where in reality Hangtabs exist on the first six possible box printings for NES Black Boxes. We’ll begin shedding light on these changes with a brief history of some of the major changes made to NES boxes (not limited to Black Box) over its lifetime.

In October 1985, the NES was released in test markets across New York City, followed by Los Angeles by early 1986, with their original lineup of 17 Black Box titles:

 

    10-Yard Fight                                      Ice Climber

     Baseball                                              Kung Fu

Clu Clu Land                                         Pinball

 Duck Hunt                                             Soccer

    Excitebike                                            Stack-Up

                  Golf                                          Super Mario Bros.

 Gyromite                                               Tennis

     Hogan’s Alley                                   Wild Gunman

Wrecking Crew

               During this test market launch in 1985 through March 1986, Nintendo had not yet begun sealing their games with shrink wrap. Instead, they used a small circular sticker that read “Nintendo” on it. In 1985, these stickers were plain “Matte” paper stickers, whereas in 1986 they upgraded to a more secure, “Glossy” metallic sticker that read “VOID” when peeled off. Sometime in 1986, Nintendo stopped using sticker seals and began shrink wrapping their games.  Production was ramping up as they began shipping in larger quantities across the nation. And just like that, by the time they launched nationwide in March 1986, we had three separate box variants.

Black Box Sticker seals

            But what about these infamous Hangtabs? Well, all of the first NES games, not just Black Boxes, had cardboard Hangtabs that were perforated into the back top portion of the box. Perhaps most useful for stores when Nintendo was sticker sealing their games, these Hangtabs existed from the first games launched in October 1985 and continued through Mid-September 1987. Nintendo was the only publisher of games for the first year of the NES and in October 1986 they opened their doors to third party publishers. This is why Hangtabs are also seen on the first games released by third-party publishers between October 1986 and September 1987. 

            So we are clear on Hangtabs, well, what about seals? And we’re not talking about the shrinkwrap–we mean the Nintendo Seal of Quality that was placed on every licensed Nintendo game to show that the game was approved by Nintendo and published by a recognized licensee (unlike unlicensed games where the seal is not present). To identify the Seal of Quality, Wata uses the abbreviation “SOQ” so as not to confuse it with a description of the method used to seal the game (such as a sticker seal versus shrink wrap seal).

              We want to make it clear that there are only two types of Nintendo SOQs for the NES: Round and Oval. Don’t be misled by descriptors online that reference the SOQ color, such as “White Seal” or “Black Seal.” These descriptors aren’t always accurate, as they can frequently be misleading since there are instances of round SOQs existing in just about every color, from black to white to gold to cyan to orange to magenta. There are also instances of games having both a circle and oval seal in the same color, so saying “white seal” here is not helpful….In creating an accurate foundation and method of identifying variants it doesn’t do any good to use colors for SOQs, since it is by no means Black and White (literally!). What IS black and white is that Nintendo used Round SOQs until March 1989, and then switched to Oval SOQs, which were  used on the rest of Nintendo’s products thereafter (even to this day). Within these changes there are yet more differences, and it should be noted here that the Oval SOQs have two versions: Oval SOQ with a TM next to it, and Oval SOQ with “®” next to it. Don’t get too confused about this, as we’ll talk more about it in the next section.

             

             So what about Hangtabs and SOQs together? It’s actually pretty straightforward. All Hangtab games have Round SOQs. Thought it was more complicated? Well, it depends on how you look at it once “Rev-A” is added to the equation. If we pay attention to the lineage, it can actually be pretty easy to understand. “Rev-A” or Revision-A was an identifier that Nintendo added to their boxes in January 1988, which was before the Oval SOQ was implemented. That’s why you can find “Rev-A” present on boxes with both Round SOQs as well as Oval SOQs. However, you won’t find an Oval SOQ WITHOUT Rev-A, since the addition of Rev-A happened some 15 months before the switch to Oval SOQs. “Rev-A” signified a change in design to the cartridges from the original 5 screw to the new 3 screw design. To denote it, Nintendo decided it was necessary to change the box, as well as the cart label and other pieces contained with the game. But we’re only talking about Box variants in this article to keep it as simple as possible–we’ll leave the other game contents for a future article.

 

The in-betweeners: how to identify the less pronounced variants

CODES & TRADEMARKS

We’ve covered some of the major variants that lay a foundation for identifying the differences in NES boxes, whether they’re Black Box or not. However, there’s a lot that happened in between those changes, and that’s especially applicable when talking about early Black Box games. If we can conquer the complicated nature of Black Box variants, the rest of the variants for Nintendo games will be a breeze. But before we jump into the smaller details that create the robust spectrum of Black Box variants, we need to fully understand why Nintendo made the changes they did. We should start by addressing two of the major causes for these smaller changes: Codes & Trademarks.

First we’ll tackle Trademarks. We start with Trademarks because the changes caused by them are not unique just to Black Box games, but to many NES titles and variants that we’ll address in the future. Generally, when companies have intellectual property that they want to protect, they’ll file a trademark — this can be for a name/wordmark or an image. Once the trademark has been filed, it is standard practice to use a “TM” next to the property that has been trademarked, signifying that it is filed for protection. However, this does not mean that it was approved by the Patent office. Once the approval is made, which can sometimes take several years, the trademark becomes “registered.” Once it is registered, the TM that was used can now be switched to a “®” indicating that it is registered property.

So why does this matter? Well, Nintendo was very protective of their brand and would seek protection on just about anything they could. Therefore, many of the properties that are present on their video game boxes in the NES years would change from having no notation, to TM, to R as they progressively filed and received approval on their various trademarks (it’s interesting to note that searching the U.S. Trademark database reveals that Nintendo would use “TM” long after their trademark became registered).

The two pieces to look out for on NES boxes are: 1) the words “Nintendo Entertainment System” (only applicable to Black Box games) and 2) the white Nintendo Seal of Quality (SOQ) image (applicable to all NES games).

So, games could either have “No NES-TM,” “NES-TM,” or “NES-R.” However, when Wata labels box variants, we don’t include “NES-R” on these variants, and not even “NES-TM” on most later variants.  This sub-variant only applies to Hangtab Black Boxes. The reason it is important to distinguish between “No NES-TM” and “NES-TM” on hangtabs is because there is a change in 1987 where the only box difference from the preceding variant is the addition of “TM” at the end of “Nintendo Entertainment System”.  Prior to mid-1987, no Black Box game had “NES-TM” on it, and once it was added, subsequent variants until April 1989 all contained the “TM” making identifying it superfluous and redundant.  The latest variants that had “NES-R” could be more easily identified by the Oval Seal that was present on each copy, since the change to NES-R and Oval Seals happened in tandem.  This means no variants exist with “NES-R” AND a circle seal.  Since there are so many changing pieces, we focus on using identifiers that highlight the actual changes so that we can leave out redundancies.  Otherwise, we’d be looking at variant descriptions 200 characters long by the last variants.

Now that we have Trademarks covered, what do we mean by “Codes?” Nintendo had two different codes that they put on their NES games, each after a certain point in the life cycle.  In Late 1986, they added the first code, which was a generic code added to the back of each Black Box game above the Nintendo logo that read “Game Pak (NES-GP)”.  Examples of a box with and without “NES-GP” are shown below.

Later on in 1987 they added the game-specific code to the top left corner on the back of each box. This code was unique to each game and had letters usually related to the title, following the formula: NES P XX (with XX being the unique letters). For example, Super Mario Bros. used the code “NES P SM”, Urban Champion used “NES P UC” and Slalom used “NES P SL”. Examples of a code and no-code box are shown to the bottom right of this page. When Wata labels these variants, we simply use the generic term “Code” to refer to this game-specific code, while “NES-GP” refers to the only other code verbatim so that there is no confusion between the two. Therefore, games can have either “No-Code” or “Code” listed on the variants, just as they can have “No NES-GP” or “NES-GP.”

 

Black Sheep of Black Boxes

ANOMALIES AND ODDITIES

Before we share our visual guides we want to cover some of the strange variants that don’t necessarily fit the Black Box narrative. It’s important to identify these properly so that they don’t become confusing when looking at everything with a wide lens and so that they can be easily recognized as outliers.

 

 

 

 

 

The Visual Guide to Black Box Collecting

BRINGING IT ALL TOGETHER

This is what we’ve been building up to. Wata Games has compiled the most definitive guide out there for you to reference so that you can track and properly identify the different Black Box variants. Included as a guide is a visual timeline of all the different variants for Super Mario Bros. We chose this title because as the most popular Black Box game (and as a launch title), it received the most box revisions possible and is only one of two known titles so far containing every variant possible (Golf being the other). Also included is a spreadsheet that maps and approximately dates what is confirmed to exist (colored GREEN and marked with an “X”), what can’t exist (colored RED), what is likely to exist yet unconfirmed (colored PURPLE), and what is unlikely to exist yet unconfirmed (colored YELLOW).  This spreadsheet chronicles the currently known box variants for all 30 Black Box titles.

 

As mentioned during the foreword at the beginning of this feature, the visual guide is supposed to be just that — a guide. Perhaps the holes that exist may one day be discovered and filled, possibly even by you the reader. As we receive submissions at Wata, we document what is received against this method of tracking variants. Being able to receive something new and undocumented, and to subsequently share it with the community, is the most exciting aspect of certification during this early era of collecting.  it enables us to paint a clearer picture and elevate the collecting hobby. We encourage you to check through your collections and see where your games fall, as you may have something you never truly realized was the first variant or an unconfirmed variant. Sharing this research with the community is paramount to completing the research itself.  We will find more when we combine efforts, so get out there and see what you can find today!

Download the spreadsheet that lays it all out!

 

9 comments

  1. Josh - Reply

    Fantastic article! Are there any examples of games that have a hangtab, circle SOQ, and rev-a designation?

  2. Dom - Reply

    Do you have any traceable/trackable sales of circle sealed nes games besides the $100 000 Super Mario. Do you have a database of your graded games such as PSA , Beckett so the consumer can see how many and which games received top grades.

    Thanks

  3. Keith Smith - Reply

    I have a super mario boxed with a different seal on it then the ones you posted.
    It says official seal of quality on it and is semi reflective gold with a white background and sports the ® mark on it.
    Any idea what version this is?

    Thanks.

Leave Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *